Home / Brokerage APIs / Alpaca vs Tradier
Alpaca vs Tradier
Both are API brokers with a hosted MCP server and a paper environment, so the details decide it. Alpaca is the better pick for crypto, official SDKs and OAuth sign-in, and Tradier is the better pick for a stock and options account with a consolidated real-time feed and published rate limits.
Short answer
OpinionPick Alpaca
if you want OAuth, SDKs and crypto
- You want crypto next to stocks and options.
- You want an official SDK.
- You want paper fills against real-time quotes.
- You want your assistant to sign in with OAuth.
Pick Tradier
if you trade only stocks and options
- You want OCO, OTO and OTOCO as separate MCP tools.
- You want real-time production data on a consolidated feed.
- You want published request limits to plan around.
- You want a documentation search tool inside the MCP server.
I rank Alpaca above Tradier for agent trading. Alpaca's hosted MCP servers sign in with OAuth and include a paper endpoint, its paper fills use real-time quotes, and its SDKs are official. Tradier's connection runs on a full-access token, and its sandbox data is delayed 15 minutes.
The company says so in its own docs. The source is linked and dated.
I ran it and this is what happened. Inputs and steps are shown.
My judgment. You may weigh the same facts differently.
At a glance
| Alpaca | Tradier | |
|---|---|---|
| Native AI agent | DocumentedAlpaca's AI offering is a set of tools for connecting outside agents: plugins, MCP servers, a CLI and agent skills.1I found no native AI agent or assistant of Alpaca's own in its documentation. | DocumentedTradier's AI features serve outside tools: a hosted MCP server for AI clients and an llms.txt file for coding assistants.23I found no native AI agent or assistant of Tradier's own in its documentation. |
| MCP server | DocumentedAlpaca hosts Trading MCP servers for live trading at https://api.alpaca.markets/mcp and for paper trading at https://paper-api.alpaca.markets/mcp, both with OAuth sign-in. Plugins connect Cursor, Claude Code and Codex. The MCP server exposes 65 tools, and an open-source local server is also available.14 | DocumentedTradier's MCP server is fully hosted and works with ChatGPT, Claude (Web, Desktop and Code), Cursor and Gemini CLI. It exposes 22 tools and authenticates with your personal access token. The connection details are on the AI Agents page in the Tradier dashboard, behind login.256I found no public MCP server URL in its documentation. |
| API and SDKs | DocumentedAlpaca supports official open-source SDKs for Python, .NET/C#, Node, Go and Java and publishes OpenAPI specifications. WebSocket streaming covers trade, account and order updates. OAuth 2.0 lets third-party apps trade for end users, and an app needs Alpaca's approval before it offers live trading to others.78910I found no Trading API order rate limits for an individual account in its documentation. | DocumentedTradier has REST APIs for trading, market data and account management, with streaming over HTTP or WebSockets. Production limits are 60 requests per minute for trading and 120 for market data. The SDKs listed in the docs are community libraries that Tradier does not maintain.11123 |
| Asset classes | DocumentedThe Trading MCP server and CLI cover stocks, ETFs, options and crypto. Multi-leg options are available for live trading, short selling is offered, and fractional orders start at $1 for over 2,000 US equities. Alpaca documents treasuries and corporate bonds for its Broker API.113141516I found no futures or forex, and no bond trading for individual Trading API accounts, in its documentation. | DocumentedThe Brokerage API covers US equities, ETFs and options only, up to a four-leg options spread or an OTOCO bracket. Futures are not available through the Brokerage API.3I found no spot crypto, forex, bonds or fractional shares through the API or MCP server in its documentation. |
| Paper trading | DocumentedPaper trading is free for all Alpaca users, and anyone globally can open a Paper Only Account with an email address. A paper account starts with a $100k balance, fills orders against real-time quotes and uses the same API spec as live. Alpaca hosts a separate MCP server for paper trading.171 | DocumentedEvery Tradier Brokerage account includes a paper trading sandbox at https://sandbox.tradier.com/v1/. Sandbox orders are paper trades filled against data delayed 15 minutes. Each MCP integration takes a PAPER_TRADING setting that selects the paper token or the live token.35 |
| Fees | DocumentedAlpaca charges no commission on US-listed securities traded through an API in self-directed individual cash accounts, and no commission on options. Crypto fees are tiered by volume and start at 0.15% maker and 0.25% taker. The free Basic data plan includes real-time equity data from IEX only. Algo Trader Plus costs $99 per month and covers all US stock exchanges.18192021 | DocumentedTradier has three plans: Lite at $0, Pro at $10 and Pro Plus at $35 per month, and API access is included on each. Stocks cost $0.35 per trade on Lite and $0.00 on Pro and Pro Plus. Equity and ETF options cost $0.35 per contract on Lite and $0.00 on the paid plans. Tradier lists a $50 per year inactivity fee for accounts with fewer than 2 trades per year.22I found nothing that says real-time market data through the API is free on every plan. |
| Account and access | DocumentedAlpaca supports accounts for individuals and businesses from around the world. A Paper Only Account needs an email address, and live trading requires onboarding with Alpaca Securities. There is no minimum deposit to open a live account, and API keys come from the dashboard. Business accounts need a $30,000 minimum deposit, and retirement accounts are not supported.231724I found no list of countries eligible for a live individual account in the pages read. | DocumentedA Tradier Brokerage account has a $0 account minimum and comes with production and sandbox tokens on the API Settings page. You need no OAuth to build against your own account. Without Partner status, API access is for personal use only.223I found nothing that says a Tradier Brokerage account is limited to US residents. |
| Order safeguards | DocumentedOAuth access is read-only unless an app requests more scopes, and trading is its own scope. The local MCP server defaults to paper trading and can be limited to chosen toolsets, such as read-only market data. Alpaca advises you to review what an agent proposes before you confirm it.941I found no Alpaca-side approval step or order-size limit for agent orders in its documentation. | DocumentedA personal token gives full account access and does not expire until you regenerate it. Token scoping is only for partner applications. You can revoke the token at any time, and the API can preview any order before sending it.32I found no confirmation step before an MCP order, and no read-only mode, in its documentation. |
Where each one wins
Alpaca
OAuth sign-in and scoped access
Alpaca's hosted MCP servers sign in with an Alpaca account over OAuth, and OAuth access is read-only unless more scopes are requested. Tradier's MCP server authenticates with a personal access token, and Tradier says an individual developer's token is full access from the moment it is created.19225
Tradier
A consolidated real-time feed in production
Tradier says production market data is real-time on a consolidated feed, with some index data delayed 15 minutes. I found no statement of whether that feed carries a fee on any plan. Alpaca's free Basic plan includes real-time equity data from IEX only, and all US stock exchanges cost $99 per month.321
Request limits are published
Tradier publishes its production limits: 60 requests per minute for trading resources and 120 for market data.12
The assistant can search the docs
Tradier's MCP server includes a search_tradier_docs tool that gives the assistant built-in documentation about API features and trading concepts.5
Sources
- AI Agent Tools. Read 2026-11-16.
- MCP/AI Connectivity | Develop | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
- Overview - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
- Trading API MCP. Read 2026-11-16.
- Tradier MCP - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
- Connecting to the MCP - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
- SDKs and Tools. Read 2026-11-16.
- Websocket Streaming. Read 2026-11-16.
- Using OAuth2 and Trading API. Read 2026-11-16.
- About Connect API. Read 2026-11-16.
- API Overview | Develop | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
- Rate Limits - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
- Options Level 3 Trading. Read 2026-11-16.
- About Trading API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Fractional Trading. Read 2026-11-16.
- Fixed Income. Read 2026-11-16.
- Paper Trading. Read 2026-11-16.
- Alpaca Support - Will I incur commission or clearing fees with Alpaca?. Read 2026-11-16.
- Alpaca Support - What are the commission fees per option contract?. Read 2026-11-16.
- Crypto Spot Trading Fees. Read 2026-11-16.
- About Market Data API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Pricing & Plans | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
- Trading Account. Read 2026-11-16.
- Alpaca - Trade with AI Using Alpaca's MCP Server. Read 2026-11-16.
- Authentication - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
- Crypto Spot Trading. Read 2026-11-16.