Trading Platform Research

Home / Brokerage APIs / Best brokerage API for AI agents

The best brokerage API for AI agents

I rank Public first for trading through an AI agent, then Robinhood, Alpaca, TradeStation and Tradier. The ranking favors brokers that ship their own agent, and the lower-ranked brokers are better at paper trading and API depth.

Documented

The company says so in its own docs. The source is linked and dated.

Observed

I ran it and this is what happened. Inputs and steps are shown.

Opinion

My judgment. You may weigh the same facts differently.

The ranking

Opinion

  1. 1

    Public

    Best overall for agent trading

    Public has its own Agents inside the account, a hosted MCP server and a REST API open to every member. Its API and MCP server cover stocks, options, bonds, event contracts and crypto. I found no paper trading in its documentation.

  2. 2

    Robinhood

    Best built-in guardrails

    Robinhood Agents runs in the app with trade approvals on by default, and an agent trades only in a dedicated account. It is still rolling out, agents cannot place multi-leg options orders, and I found no stock or options REST API in its documentation.

  3. 3

    Alpaca

    Best API and best paper trading

    I found no agent of Alpaca's own, and it has the most complete kit for yours: hosted MCP servers for live and paper, 65 tools, five official SDKs and free paper trading open to anyone with an email address.

  4. 4

    TradeStation

    Best for futures

    TradeStation's API trades stocks, options and futures, and its MCP requires explicit confirmation before orders. MCP access is requested in HUB, and the Trading API signup steps call for a $10,000 minimum balance.

  5. 5

    Tradier

    Best low-cost start for stocks and options

    Tradier includes API access, an MCP server and a paper sandbox on its free plan, with a $0 account minimum. It trades US equities, ETFs and options only, and an MCP connection runs on a token with full account access.

What agent-first means here

I call a brokerage agent-first when its documentation treats an AI agent as a normal way to place an order. I looked for three things: an agent of the broker's own, an official MCP server, and controls over what an agent may do. Nothing in this section was tested hands-on, so every fact comes from the brokers' own pages.

Opinion

A native agent counts most

A broker that hosts the agent removes the setup. You need no keys, no outside AI client and no server. Public and Robinhood are the two brokers here that document an agent of their own, and that is why they rank first and second.

Documented

All five have an official MCP server

Public, Robinhood and Alpaca publish their MCP endpoints. Tradier keeps its connection details on a dashboard page behind login, and TradeStation clients request access in HUB.12345

Documented

Public ranks first on reach

Public's API and hosted MCP server support stocks and ETFs, equity and index options, corporate bonds and treasuries, event contracts and crypto. Robinhood says agents can place long equities, options and crypto orders, and that Robinhood Agents is still rolling out.678

Opinion

This is a ranking for agents, and API quality is a separate question

The order would change for a developer who wants the best API. Alpaca would lead on SDKs, OAuth scopes and paper trading, and Robinhood would fall, because the one REST trading API I found in its documentation covers crypto.

Native agents versus your own agent over MCP

A native agent is built and run by the broker. With MCP you bring an AI client such as Claude or ChatGPT and connect it to the account. The difference that matters most is who has to say yes before an order goes out.

Documented

Public: approve the workflow once

At Public you describe a task, the AI proposes an Agent workflow, and the Agent needs your explicit sign-off before it runs. Once it is active, Public does not wait for your confirmation before each transaction.910

Documented

Robinhood: approvals on for its agent, off for yours

Robinhood turns trade approvals on by default for its built-in agent and off by default for MCP accounts used by external agents. With approvals on, the agent proposes trades and you place them in the app. With approvals off, the agent can place eligible trades without your confirmation of each order.7118

Documented

The three API brokers treat an outside agent differently

TradeStation MCP requires explicit confirmation before orders are placed. Alpaca advises you to review what your agent proposes, and its OAuth access is read-only unless more scopes are requested. A Tradier connection uses a personal token that is full account access, which you can revoke at any time.53121314

Documented

The brokers say they do not supervise your agent

Public and Robinhood each say they do not control, supervise, monitor, recommend or audit third-party AI agents. Tradier says it does not supervise or approve the outputs of third-party AI applications.151617

What it costs

None of the five documents a subscription fee for its MCP server. The costs sit in commissions, monthly plans, market data, model tokens and the balance you need to get in.

Documented

The agent connection itself

Public says MCP access is included with a brokerage account at no extra cost. Tradier says its MCP server works with any plan, including the free Lite plan. TradeStation says access to add its connector comes from your AI provider and is not billed by TradeStation.15145

Documented

Robinhood's built-in agent bills by the token

Every message to a Robinhood built-in agent uses tokens, charged at the model's public token cost and rounded to the nearest cent. You receive $5 in tokens when you open your first Agentic account. Token billing applies only to agents hosted on Robinhood.18

Documented

Stock commissions

Public describes API trading as commission-free, Robinhood is commission-free for stocks, ETFs and their options, and Alpaca charges no commission on US-listed securities traded through an API in individual cash accounts. TradeStation lists $0 commission per share for stocks and ETFs. Tradier charges $0.35 per stock trade on its free Lite plan and $0.00 on Pro and Pro Plus.1920212223

Documented

The balance you need to get in

TradeStation's Trading API signup steps call for a minimum balance of $10,000. The Tradier Brokerage account minimum is $0, and Alpaca has no minimum deposit to open a live account.242325

Documented

Alpaca charges for full real-time stock data

Alpaca's free Basic plan includes real-time equity data from IEX only. Algo Trader Plus costs $99 per month and covers all US stock exchanges.26

What each one cannot trade or test

The asset lists below come from each broker's documentation for its API, MCP server or agents. Each broker's profile page notes what I looked for and did not find.

Documented

Public: five asset groups, with one MCP limit

Public's API and hosted MCP server list stocks and ETFs, equity and index options, corporate bonds and treasuries, event contracts and crypto. The MCP server can only buy event contracts, so selling them takes the Public app or the API.627

Documented

Robinhood: single-leg and long only

Robinhood agents can place long equities, options and crypto orders. They cannot place multi-leg options orders, and margin borrowing is not available in Agentic accounts.711

Documented

Alpaca: bonds sit in a different API

Alpaca's Trading MCP server and CLI cover stocks, ETFs, options and crypto. Alpaca documents treasuries and corporate bonds as available through the Broker API, and its MCP fixed-income toolset is limited to latest quotes.32829

Documented

TradeStation: the one with futures

The TradeStation API supports stocks, options and futures trading under the same interface.30

Documented

Tradier: stocks, ETFs and options only

Tradier's Brokerage API covers US equities, ETFs and options only, and lists futures as not available.13

Documented

Three of the five have a paper environment

Alpaca's paper trading is free for all users and has its own hosted MCP server. TradeStation has a Simulator API that matches the live API. Every Tradier Brokerage account includes a paper trading sandbox, with orders filled against data delayed 15 minutes.3133213

Documented

At Public and Robinhood, orders are real

Public states that an order through any MCP client is a real order using real money. Robinhood's review tools simulate a single order and return pre-trade warnings before it is placed.17

Opinion

The two top-ranked brokers are the two I would not test on

I found no paper account in Public's or Robinhood's documentation. If you are writing your own agent, build and test it on Alpaca, TradeStation or Tradier first. If futures are the point, TradeStation moves to the top of this list.

Sources

  1. Connect the Public Hosted MCP Server to Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Muse, Perplexity, and Grok | AI Trading Setup. Read 2026-11-16.
  2. Onboarding an external agent | Robinhood. Read 2026-11-16.
  3. AI Agent Tools. Read 2026-11-16.
  4. Connecting to the MCP - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
  5. TradeStation MCP: AI Tools for Your Account | TradeStation. Read 2026-11-16.
  6. Public brokerage API for Algorithmic Trading | Stocks, Options & Crypto. Read 2026-11-16.
  7. Trading with your agent | Robinhood. Read 2026-11-16.
  8. Robinhood Agents overview | Robinhood. Read 2026-11-16.
  9. AI Agents for Investing - Public.com. Read 2026-11-16.
  10. Agentic Brokerage Disclosure (PDF). Read 2026-11-16.
  11. Setting up an agent | Robinhood. Read 2026-11-16.
  12. Using OAuth2 and Trading API. Read 2026-11-16.
  13. Overview - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
  14. MCP/AI Connectivity | Develop | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
  15. Public MCP Server for trading on AI platforms. Read 2026-11-16.
  16. Robinhood Agents | Build Your AI Trading Agent. Read 2026-11-16.
  17. MCP Data Disclosure | Legal | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
  18. Token usage billing | Robinhood. Read 2026-11-16.
  19. Public Trading API – Automate Stocks & Options Orders. Read 2026-11-16.
  20. Trading fees on Robinhood | Robinhood. Read 2026-11-16.
  21. Alpaca Support - Will I incur commission or clearing fees with Alpaca?. Read 2026-11-16.
  22. Pricing Commissions & Fees | TradeStation. Read 2026-11-16.
  23. Pricing & Plans | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
  24. Trading API | The Full Power of TradeStation. Read 2026-11-16.
  25. Alpaca - Trade with AI Using Alpaca's MCP Server. Read 2026-11-16.
  26. About Market Data API. Read 2026-11-16.
  27. FAQ | Public API. Read 2026-11-16.
  28. Fixed Income. Read 2026-11-16.
  29. Trading API MCP. Read 2026-11-16.
  30. TradeStation API Docs | TradeStation API. Read 2026-11-16.
  31. Paper Trading. Read 2026-11-16.
  32. SIM vs. LIVE | TradeStation API. Read 2026-11-16.