Home / Brokerage APIs / Public vs Alpaca
Public vs Alpaca
Public is the better pick if you want the brokerage to run the agent for you, and for bonds and event contracts. Alpaca is the better pick if you are building your own agent and want free paper trading, five official SDKs and read-only access scopes.
Short answer
OpinionPick Public
if you want an agent without building one
- You want to describe a task in a prompt and approve a workflow.
- You want corporate bonds, treasuries or event contracts through the API.
- You want API trading in an IRA.
- You want index options.
Pick Alpaca
if you are building and testing your own agent
- You want to test against a paper account before any money moves.
- You want an official SDK in Python, .NET, Node, Go or Java.
- You want to give an agent read-only access.
- You are building an app that trades for other people.
I rank Public above Alpaca for agent trading because Public runs an agent inside the account and Alpaca leaves the agent to you. For a developer who writes and tests an agent, Alpaca is the stronger API. Its paper environment, SDK list and OAuth scopes go further than anything Public documents.
The company says so in its own docs. The source is linked and dated.
I ran it and this is what happened. Inputs and steps are shown.
My judgment. You may weigh the same facts differently.
At a glance
| Public | Alpaca | |
|---|---|---|
| Native AI agent | DocumentedAgents is built into the Public account. You describe a task in a prompt, the AI proposes a workflow, and nothing executes until you approve it. Agents monitor markets, place trades and move cash, with no API keys to generate. Public says some of the example Agent capabilities on its page are not yet available.12I found no price for Agents, and no statement that every account has them, in its documentation. | DocumentedAlpaca's AI offering is a set of tools for connecting outside agents: plugins, MCP servers, a CLI and agent skills.3I found no native AI agent or assistant of Alpaca's own in its documentation. |
| MCP server | DocumentedPublic hosts an MCP server at https://mcp.public.com/mcp and documents setup for Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Meta Muse, Perplexity and Grok. Most assistants sign in with OAuth. A connected agent is authorized to view account data and place trades.456 | DocumentedAlpaca hosts Trading MCP servers for live trading at https://api.alpaca.markets/mcp and for paper trading at https://paper-api.alpaca.markets/mcp, both with OAuth sign-in. Plugins connect Cursor, Claude Code and Codex. The MCP server exposes 65 tools, and an open-source local server is also available.37 |
| API and SDKs | DocumentedPublic has a REST API with an official Python SDK, a CLI and Postman collections. WebSocket streams push order updates and trades. The rate limit is 10 requests per second per account, and the Individual API is for personal, non-commercial use.58 | DocumentedAlpaca supports official open-source SDKs for Python, .NET/C#, Node, Go and Java and publishes OpenAPI specifications. WebSocket streaming covers trade, account and order updates. OAuth 2.0 lets third-party apps trade for end users, and an app needs Alpaca's approval before it offers live trading to others.9101112I found no Trading API order rate limits for an individual account in its documentation. |
| Asset classes | DocumentedThe API and hosted MCP server trade stocks and ETFs, equity and index options, corporate bonds and treasuries, event contracts and crypto. Agents trade stocks, options and crypto, including multi-leg options. The MCP server can only buy event contracts.1315I found no futures or forex in its API, MCP or Agents documentation. | DocumentedThe Trading MCP server and CLI cover stocks, ETFs, options and crypto. Multi-leg options are available for live trading, short selling is offered, and fractional orders start at $1 for over 2,000 US equities. Alpaca documents treasuries and corporate bonds for its Broker API.314151617I found no futures or forex, and no bond trading for individual Trading API accounts, in its documentation. |
| Paper trading | DocumentedPublic states that an order placed through any MCP client is a real order using real money. Preflight endpoints return the estimated cost, commission and fees without placing anything.45I found no paper trading or sandbox for the API, the MCP server or Agents in its documentation. | DocumentedPaper trading is free for all Alpaca users, and anyone globally can open a Paper Only Account with an email address. A paper account starts with a $100k balance, fills orders against real-time quotes and uses the same API spec as live. Alpaca hosts a separate MCP server for paper trading.183 |
| Fees | DocumentedThe API and the MCP server cost nothing to use, and Public describes API trading as commission-free. Crypto fees start at 0.60% for the first $10K of monthly volume and fall to 0.10% above $100M. Index options are $0.35 per contract. Options contracts traded via the API earn a rebate of $0.06 per contract in Tiers 1-3 and $0.10 in Tier 4.86519 | DocumentedAlpaca charges no commission on US-listed securities traded through an API in self-directed individual cash accounts, and no commission on options. Crypto fees are tiered by volume and start at 0.15% maker and 0.25% taker. The free Basic data plan includes real-time equity data from IEX only. Algo Trader Plus costs $99 per month and covers all US stock exchanges.20212223 |
| Account and access | DocumentedAny Public member can generate an API key with no approval step, and the hosted MCP server needs a Public brokerage account. The API works with cash, margin, IRA and business accounts. International accounts face restrictions on API use.84I found no account minimum or residency requirement in the pages read. | DocumentedAlpaca supports accounts for individuals and businesses from around the world. A Paper Only Account needs an email address, and live trading requires onboarding with Alpaca Securities. There is no minimum deposit to open a live account, and API keys come from the dashboard. Business accounts need a $30,000 minimum deposit, and retirement accounts are not supported.241825I found no list of countries eligible for a live individual account in the pages read. |
| Order safeguards | DocumentedEach Agent needs your sign-off on its workflow before it runs. Once it is active, Public does not wait for your confirmation before each transaction. You can pause, edit or shut down an Agent at any time, and it logs every action. Public discloses that an outside agent on MCP may trade without your input on each transaction.1266I found no read-only scope for the API or the hosted MCP server in its documentation. | DocumentedOAuth access is read-only unless an app requests more scopes, and trading is its own scope. The local MCP server defaults to paper trading and can be limited to chosen toolsets, such as read-only market data. Alpaca advises you to review what an agent proposes before you confirm it.1173I found no Alpaca-side approval step or order-size limit for agent orders in its documentation. |
Where each one wins
Public
Bonds, treasuries and event contracts
Public's API and MCP server trade corporate bonds, treasuries and event contracts alongside stocks, options and crypto. Alpaca's Trading MCP server and CLI cover stocks, ETFs, options and crypto, and Alpaca documents treasuries and corporate bonds for its Broker API.13317
Alpaca
Sources
- AI Agents for Investing - Public.com. Read 2026-11-16.
- AI Agents Prompting Guide - Public.com. Read 2026-11-16.
- AI Agent Tools. Read 2026-11-16.
- Connect the Public Hosted MCP Server to Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Muse, Perplexity, and Grok | AI Trading Setup. Read 2026-11-16.
- FAQ | Public API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Public MCP Server for trading on AI platforms. Read 2026-11-16.
- Trading API MCP. Read 2026-11-16.
- Public Trading API – Automate Stocks & Options Orders. Read 2026-11-16.
- SDKs and Tools. Read 2026-11-16.
- Websocket Streaming. Read 2026-11-16.
- Using OAuth2 and Trading API. Read 2026-11-16.
- About Connect API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Public brokerage API for Algorithmic Trading | Stocks, Options & Crypto. Read 2026-11-16.
- Options Level 3 Trading. Read 2026-11-16.
- About Trading API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Fractional Trading. Read 2026-11-16.
- Fixed Income. Read 2026-11-16.
- Paper Trading. Read 2026-11-16.
- Public Fee Schedule (PDF). Read 2026-11-16.
- Alpaca Support - Will I incur commission or clearing fees with Alpaca?. Read 2026-11-16.
- Alpaca Support - What are the commission fees per option contract?. Read 2026-11-16.
- Crypto Spot Trading Fees. Read 2026-11-16.
- About Market Data API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Trading Account. Read 2026-11-16.
- Alpaca - Trade with AI Using Alpaca's MCP Server. Read 2026-11-16.
- Agentic Brokerage Disclosure (PDF). Read 2026-11-16.