Home / Brokerage APIs / Public vs TradeStation
Public vs TradeStation
Public is the better pick for an agent you can set up yourself: it has its own Agents, a published MCP endpoint and an API key with no approval step. TradeStation is the better pick for futures, a simulator and an MCP connection that confirms every order.
Short answer
OpinionPick Public
if you want to set up an agent yourself
- You want a built-in agent that works from a prompt.
- You want to generate an API key with no approval step.
- You want crypto, bonds or event contracts.
- You want an official Python SDK.
Pick TradeStation
if you trade futures or want a simulator
- You trade futures alongside stocks and options.
- You want a simulator that mirrors the live API.
- You want explicit confirmation before an AI assistant places an order.
- You need FIX connectivity.
I rank Public above TradeStation for agent trading. Public documents a native agent, a public MCP endpoint and self-serve keys, while TradeStation's MCP access is requested and its API signup calls for a $10,000 balance. TradeStation is the one of the two with futures and a documented paper environment.
The company says so in its own docs. The source is linked and dated.
I ran it and this is what happened. Inputs and steps are shown.
My judgment. You may weigh the same facts differently.
At a glance
| Public | TradeStation | |
|---|---|---|
| Native AI agent | DocumentedAgents is built into the Public account. You describe a task in a prompt, the AI proposes a workflow, and nothing executes until you approve it. Agents monitor markets, place trades and move cash, with no API keys to generate. Public says some of the example Agent capabilities on its page are not yet available.12I found no price for Agents, and no statement that every account has them, in its documentation. | DocumentedInsights AI is a market-intelligence page that TradeStation builds from news and market data with generative AI. EasyLanguage is its syntax-based programming language for automating orders.34I found no native AI agent or assistant that places trades in its documentation. |
| MCP server | DocumentedPublic hosts an MCP server at https://mcp.public.com/mcp and documents setup for Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Meta Muse, Perplexity and Grok. Most assistants sign in with OAuth. A connected agent is authorized to view account data and place trades.567 | DocumentedTradeStation MCP connects an existing TradeStation account to Claude or ChatGPT, with more AI platforms in development. Clients request access on the Platforms page in HUB. The connection requires explicit confirmation before orders are placed.8I found no published server URL, authentication method or tool list for TradeStation MCP. |
| API and SDKs | DocumentedPublic has a REST API with an official Python SDK, a CLI and Postman collections. WebSocket streams push order updates and trades. The rate limit is 10 requests per second per account, and the Individual API is for personal, non-commercial use.69 | DocumentedTradeStation has a REST API, with v3 recommended, plus FIX connectivity and streaming endpoints for options chains, market depth, quotes, orders and positions. It supports bracket, OCO, OSO and multi-leg options orders. API keys use the Auth Code Flow by default.101112I found no official SDK in its documentation. |
| Asset classes | DocumentedThe API and hosted MCP server trade stocks and ETFs, equity and index options, corporate bonds and treasuries, event contracts and crypto. Agents trade stocks, options and crypto, including multi-leg options. The MCP server can only buy event contracts.1316I found no futures or forex in its API, MCP or Agents documentation. | DocumentedThe TradeStation API supports stocks, options and futures trading from a single API key.1011I found no crypto, forex, bonds or fractional shares through the API in its documentation. I found no tool list for TradeStation MCP, so I cannot say which of these assets it trades. |
| Paper trading | DocumentedPublic states that an order placed through any MCP client is a real order using real money. Preflight endpoints return the estimated cost, commission and fees without placing anything.56I found no paper trading or sandbox for the API, the MCP server or Agents in its documentation. | DocumentedA Simulator API mirrors the live API with fake accounts and simulated instant fills, at https://sim-api.tradestation.com/v3. The simulated trading environment covers stocks, options and futures, with unlimited paper dollars and balance resets.144I found nothing that says the Simulator API works without a funded live account. |
| Fees | DocumentedThe API and the MCP server cost nothing to use, and Public describes API trading as commission-free. Crypto fees start at 0.60% for the first $10K of monthly volume and fall to 0.10% above $100M. Index options are $0.35 per contract. Options contracts traded via the API earn a rebate of $0.06 per contract in Tiers 1-3 and $0.10 in Tier 4.97615 | DocumentedAPI access has no subscription cost. US stocks and ETFs are $0 commission per share. Single-leg options cost between $0 and $0.80 per contract, per side, depending on monthly volume tier, and futures are as low as $0.50 per contract, per side. Access to add the MCP connector comes from your AI provider and is not billed by TradeStation.1116178I found no TradeStation fee for MCP stated either way. |
| Account and access | DocumentedAny Public member can generate an API key with no approval step, and the hosted MCP server needs a Public brokerage account. The API works with cash, margin, IRA and business accounts. International accounts face restrictions on API use.95I found no account minimum or residency requirement in the pages read. | DocumentedAn API key requires a TradeStation account and is requested by email from Client Experience. The Trading API signup steps call for a minimum balance of $10,000. TradeStation says MCP requires no account minimum. Unless you are a TradeStation partner, API access is restricted to the accounts under your own login.18111912 |
| Order safeguards | DocumentedEach Agent needs your sign-off on its workflow before it runs. Once it is active, Public does not wait for your confirmation before each transaction. You can pause, edit or shut down an Agent at any time, and it logs every action. Public discloses that an outside agent on MCP may trade without your input on each transaction.1207I found no read-only scope for the API or the hosted MCP server in its documentation. | DocumentedTradeStation MCP requires explicit confirmation before orders are placed, and all actions stay subject to your existing trading permissions and risk controls. API scopes separate market data, account reading and trading.821I found nothing that says TradeStation MCP is read-only by default or scoped apart from the API's Trade scope. |
Where each one wins
Public
TradeStation
FIX and streaming market depth
TradeStation's developer platform provides REST and FIX connectivity, and its API has streaming endpoints for market depth, options chains and quotes.11
Sources
- AI Agents for Investing - Public.com. Read 2026-11-16.
- AI Agents Prompting Guide - Public.com. Read 2026-11-16.
- Insights AI. Read 2026-11-16.
- Test Your Strategies With Our Trading Simulator. Read 2026-11-16.
- Connect the Public Hosted MCP Server to Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Muse, Perplexity, and Grok | AI Trading Setup. Read 2026-11-16.
- FAQ | Public API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Public MCP Server for trading on AI platforms. Read 2026-11-16.
- TradeStation MCP: AI Tools for Your Account | TradeStation. Read 2026-11-16.
- Public Trading API – Automate Stocks & Options Orders. Read 2026-11-16.
- TradeStation API Docs | TradeStation API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Trading API | The Full Power of TradeStation. Read 2026-11-16.
- Overview | TradeStation API (Authentication). Read 2026-11-16.
- Public brokerage API for Algorithmic Trading | Stocks, Options & Crypto. Read 2026-11-16.
- SIM vs. LIVE | TradeStation API. Read 2026-11-16.
- Public Fee Schedule (PDF). Read 2026-11-16.
- Pricing Commissions & Fees | TradeStation. Read 2026-11-16.
- TradeStation llms-full.txt. Read 2026-11-16.
- Frequently Asked Questions | TradeStation API. Read 2026-11-16.
- TradeStation | Online Trading And Brokerage Services. Read 2026-11-16.
- Agentic Brokerage Disclosure (PDF). Read 2026-11-16.
- Scopes | TradeStation API. Read 2026-11-16.