Trading Platform Research

Home / Brokerage APIs / Public vs Tradier

Public vs Tradier

Public is the better pick for a built-in agent, commission-free trades without a monthly plan, and crypto or bonds. Tradier is the better pick if your agent trades only stocks and options and you want a paper sandbox included with the account.

Short answer

Opinion

Pick Public

if you want an agent and more to trade

  • You want an agent inside the brokerage.
  • You want crypto, bonds or event contracts.
  • You want your assistant to sign in with OAuth.
  • You want fractional or dollar-based orders.

Pick Tradier

if you trade stocks and options and want a sandbox

  • You want to test in paper trading before using real capital.
  • You want the MCP tool list published in the docs.
  • You trade enough index options to pay for a $35 monthly plan.
  • You want OCO, OTO and OTOCO tools in the MCP server.
Opinion: my overall ranking

I rank Public above Tradier for agent trading. Public has its own agent, more asset groups and OAuth sign-in for most assistants, while a Tradier connection runs on a token with full account access. Tradier includes a paper sandbox with every account, and I found no paper trading in Public's documentation.

Documented

The company says so in its own docs. The source is linked and dated.

Observed

I ran it and this is what happened. Inputs and steps are shown.

Opinion

My judgment. You may weigh the same facts differently.

At a glance

A bar on the left edge of a cell marks the platform with the advantage on that row.
PublicTradier
Native AI agentDocumentedAgents is built into the Public account. You describe a task in a prompt, the AI proposes a workflow, and nothing executes until you approve it. Agents monitor markets, place trades and move cash, with no API keys to generate. Public says some of the example Agent capabilities on its page are not yet available.12I found no price for Agents, and no statement that every account has them, in its documentation.DocumentedTradier's AI features serve outside tools: a hosted MCP server for AI clients and an llms.txt file for coding assistants.34I found no native AI agent or assistant of Tradier's own in its documentation.
MCP serverDocumentedPublic hosts an MCP server at https://mcp.public.com/mcp and documents setup for Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Meta Muse, Perplexity and Grok. Most assistants sign in with OAuth. A connected agent is authorized to view account data and place trades.567DocumentedTradier's MCP server is fully hosted and works with ChatGPT, Claude (Web, Desktop and Code), Cursor and Gemini CLI. It exposes 22 tools and authenticates with your personal access token. The connection details are on the AI Agents page in the Tradier dashboard, behind login.389I found no public MCP server URL in its documentation.
API and SDKsDocumentedPublic has a REST API with an official Python SDK, a CLI and Postman collections. WebSocket streams push order updates and trades. The rate limit is 10 requests per second per account, and the Individual API is for personal, non-commercial use.610DocumentedTradier has REST APIs for trading, market data and account management, with streaming over HTTP or WebSockets. Production limits are 60 requests per minute for trading and 120 for market data. The SDKs listed in the docs are community libraries that Tradier does not maintain.11124
Asset classesDocumentedThe API and hosted MCP server trade stocks and ETFs, equity and index options, corporate bonds and treasuries, event contracts and crypto. Agents trade stocks, options and crypto, including multi-leg options. The MCP server can only buy event contracts.1316I found no futures or forex in its API, MCP or Agents documentation.DocumentedThe Brokerage API covers US equities, ETFs and options only, up to a four-leg options spread or an OTOCO bracket. Futures are not available through the Brokerage API.4I found no spot crypto, forex, bonds or fractional shares through the API or MCP server in its documentation.
Paper tradingDocumentedPublic states that an order placed through any MCP client is a real order using real money. Preflight endpoints return the estimated cost, commission and fees without placing anything.56I found no paper trading or sandbox for the API, the MCP server or Agents in its documentation.DocumentedEvery Tradier Brokerage account includes a paper trading sandbox at https://sandbox.tradier.com/v1/. Sandbox orders are paper trades filled against data delayed 15 minutes. Each MCP integration takes a PAPER_TRADING setting that selects the paper token or the live token.48
FeesDocumentedThe API and the MCP server cost nothing to use, and Public describes API trading as commission-free. Crypto fees start at 0.60% for the first $10K of monthly volume and fall to 0.10% above $100M. Index options are $0.35 per contract. Options contracts traded via the API earn a rebate of $0.06 per contract in Tiers 1-3 and $0.10 in Tier 4.107614DocumentedTradier has three plans: Lite at $0, Pro at $10 and Pro Plus at $35 per month, and API access is included on each. Stocks cost $0.35 per trade on Lite and $0.00 on Pro and Pro Plus. Equity and ETF options cost $0.35 per contract on Lite and $0.00 on the paid plans. Tradier lists a $50 per year inactivity fee for accounts with fewer than 2 trades per year.15I found nothing that says real-time market data through the API is free on every plan.
Account and accessDocumentedAny Public member can generate an API key with no approval step, and the hosted MCP server needs a Public brokerage account. The API works with cash, margin, IRA and business accounts. International accounts face restrictions on API use.105I found no account minimum or residency requirement in the pages read.DocumentedA Tradier Brokerage account has a $0 account minimum and comes with production and sandbox tokens on the API Settings page. You need no OAuth to build against your own account. Without Partner status, API access is for personal use only.154I found nothing that says a Tradier Brokerage account is limited to US residents.
Order safeguardsDocumentedEach Agent needs your sign-off on its workflow before it runs. Once it is active, Public does not wait for your confirmation before each transaction. You can pause, edit or shut down an Agent at any time, and it logs every action. Public discloses that an outside agent on MCP may trade without your input on each transaction.1167I found no read-only scope for the API or the hosted MCP server in its documentation.DocumentedA personal token gives full account access and does not expire until you regenerate it. Token scoping is only for partner applications. You can revoke the token at any time, and the API can preview any order before sending it.43I found no confirmation step before an MCP order, and no read-only mode, in its documentation.

Where each one wins

Public

Documented

An agent of its own

Public's Agents are built from a prompt and run inside the account. Tradier's AI features are a hosted MCP server for AI tools and an llms.txt file for coding assistants.134

Documented

OAuth sign-in for most assistants

Most assistants connect to Public's MCP server with OAuth, so you sign in and never share a key. Tradier's MCP server authenticates with a personal access token, which is full account access and does not expire until you regenerate it.634

Documented

No commission without a monthly plan

Public describes API trading as commission-free and charges nothing for API access. On Tradier's free Lite plan, stocks cost $0.35 per trade and equity and ETF options cost $0.35 per contract, and the $10 Pro plan brings both to $0.00.1015

Documented

More asset groups, and fractional orders

Public's API trades bonds, event contracts and crypto as well as stocks and options, and its market and limit orders accept a fractional quantity or a dollar amount. Tradier's Brokerage API covers US equities, ETFs and options only.1364

Documented

A higher request limit

Public allows 10 requests per second per account across all endpoints. Tradier limits trading resources to 60 requests per minute.612

Tradier

Documented

A paper sandbox with every account

Every Tradier Brokerage account includes a paper trading sandbox, and each MCP integration has a PAPER_TRADING setting. Sandbox orders fill against data delayed 15 minutes. Public states that an order through any MCP client is a real order using real money.485

Documented

The MCP tools are documented in full

Tradier documents 22 MCP tools, including six order tools and a tool that searches its documentation. Public's open-source MCP server lists place_order, place_multileg_order and cancel_order among its write tools.817

Documented

Cheaper index options on Pro Plus

Index options cost $0.10 per contract on Tradier's $35 Pro Plus plan. Public's fee schedule lists index options at $0.35 per contract.1514

Sources

  1. AI Agents for Investing - Public.com. Read 2026-11-16.
  2. AI Agents Prompting Guide - Public.com. Read 2026-11-16.
  3. MCP/AI Connectivity | Develop | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
  4. Overview - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
  5. Connect the Public Hosted MCP Server to Claude, ChatGPT, Codex, Muse, Perplexity, and Grok | AI Trading Setup. Read 2026-11-16.
  6. FAQ | Public API. Read 2026-11-16.
  7. Public MCP Server for trading on AI platforms. Read 2026-11-16.
  8. Tradier MCP - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
  9. Connecting to the MCP - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
  10. Public Trading API – Automate Stocks & Options Orders. Read 2026-11-16.
  11. API Overview | Develop | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
  12. Rate Limits - Tradier Documentation. Read 2026-11-16.
  13. Public brokerage API for Algorithmic Trading | Stocks, Options & Crypto. Read 2026-11-16.
  14. Public Fee Schedule (PDF). Read 2026-11-16.
  15. Pricing & Plans | Tradier. Read 2026-11-16.
  16. Agentic Brokerage Disclosure (PDF). Read 2026-11-16.
  17. Public.com MCP Server (README, PublicDotCom/publicdotcom-mcp-server). Read 2026-11-16.